Most owners don’t lose a Lake County tax appeal because their point is “wrong.” They lose because the filing is late, incomplete, or not supported by the type of evidence the Board requires.
The fastest way to improve your odds is to treat the appeal like a clean proof file: state your reason, attach the right documents, and follow the Board’s rules so you do not forfeit the right to keep appealing that year.
Deadline reality: Lake County appeals must be filed on or before 30 days after the publication of current assessments for your township, and the specific deadline is listed on your assessment notice. Missing the criteria can mean no hearing, no decision, and no further appeal for that assessment year.
Below, we’ll walk through the process in the same order the county expects: (1) talk to your township assessor, (2) file correctly (usually online), (3) choose your basis for appeal, (4) pick your hearing type, and (5) submit evidence that matches the basis you selected.
Confirm your deadline
Send your assessment notice and township. We’ll confirm the filing window and what evidence fits your best argument.
The Big Picture: Who Decides What in Lake County
In Lake County, the Board of Review has authority to raise, lower, or sustain assessments as it appears just. The typical appellant is a property owner who disagrees with their assessment.
Before you ever file, the county strongly encourages contacting your local township assessor—and in some categories (like factual error and vacancy for income-producing commercial property), contacting the township assessor is actually required first.
Why the Township Assessor Step Matters
A surprising number of disputes can be clarified (or even resolved) at the township level once you review the property record.
Use this step to confirm the facts the county is using to value your property:
- Characteristics: size, improvements, basement type, lot details
- Classification/use: how the property is categorized
- Errors: anything that is plainly incorrect on the record
Practical rule: If your appeal depends on a fact (square footage, vacancy, condition), you should have a document or photo that proves it—before you file.
Once you confirm your facts, you can file with a clearer strategy—and you avoid building an entire case on an incorrect record.
Filing an Appeal: The 30-Day Window and the Online Portals
Lake County’s filing rule is simple but unforgiving: you must submit the prescribed forms with required evidence on or before 30 days after publication of current assessments for your township.
The county also explains that appeals must be filed electronically and begin through the Chief County Assessment Office’s SmartFile E-Filing Portal for most townships.
Important Lake County detail: A small group of townships uses a different software system. For those townships, you may need to use the township portal first to create a comparable grid, then return to SmartFile to complete the filing.
The safest workflow is: confirm your township, confirm your deadline from the notice, then follow the county’s instructions for your township’s portal path before you upload anything.
Build a clean appeal packet
We can organize comps, grids, and documents into a Board-friendly submission that is easy to verify.
Reasons to Appeal (And the Evidence That Fits Each One)
Lake County outlines common bases for appeal. Your job is to pick the one that matches your facts and then attach the evidence the Board expects for that basis.
Typical bases include:
- Factual error: incorrect square footage or property characteristics
- Recent sale price test: assessment is greater than 1/3 of the property’s recent sale price
- Market value test: assessment is greater than 1/3 of market value
- Comparable properties: your assessment is higher than comparable properties
- Matters of law
Match the proof to the claim: The Board specifies evidence requirements on the appeal form and in the Board’s Rules. If your packet doesn’t meet the criteria, the Board may not schedule a hearing or issue a decision.
Hearing Type: Letter Review vs. Phone, In-Person, or Zoom
Lake County allows several hearing formats: letter, phone, in-person, or Zoom video (the county notes Zoom as preferred). If you choose a letter appeal, the Board decides based on the written evidence submitted by you and the township assessor’s office.
The county describes letter review as the easiest format because you do not have to appear or remember to call at a designated time. And while any appeal may be reviewed by letter, the county highlights two residential scenarios that are particularly well-suited for letter review when accompanied by the required evidence.
Two Residential Appeals That Often Fit Letter Review
1) Appeal based on recent sale price:
Possible evidence includes a signed Settlement Statement, signed HUD-1, MLS listing history, and the recorded Illinois Real Estate Transfer Declaration (PTAX-203).
2) Appeal based on fair cash value:
Possible evidence includes an appraisal and/or comparable sales selected from the assessment neighborhood and “gridded” on the appropriate county form.
If you choose a live hearing: the county explains it typically begins with swearing-in, then testimony/evidence from the appellant and the township assessor, questions, rebuttal, and Board deliberation—with hearings scheduled about every 15 minutes.
Translation: if you want the hearing to go smoothly, your evidence must be organized, easy to reference, and directly tied to the basis you selected—because the timeline is tight.
How to Build a Board-Friendly Evidence Packet
Lake County’s online filing system supports researching comparable sales and assessments, and the county provides a comparable property grid that can be uploaded with your appeal. A clean grid plus a short explanation often beats a messy upload folder.
Use a simple structure:
- Your reason for appeal (one paragraph)
- Your requested conclusion (the value/result you believe is supported)
- Labeled exhibits (grid, comps, appraisal, sale docs, photos, corrections)
Don’t bury the lead. Make it obvious what you want and why the evidence supports it. Reviewers should not have to hunt for your point.
If you’re submitting documents from a recent transaction or an appraisal, upload the cleanest versions and remove pages that don’t support your argument. Quality beats volume.
What Happens If You Have Questions (and What Happens If You Miss a Step)
Lake County explains that the appeal form, Board rules, and website are designed to be instructive, and that the Chief County Assessment Office has taxpayer advocates available each business day to assist with assessment and appeal process questions.
Do not wing the rules. Lake County warns that if filing criteria are not met, the Board may not schedule a hearing or render a decision—and you may forfeit the right to further appeal the current assessment.
If you feel overwhelmed, the best first move is still simple: confirm your deadline, confirm your township path (SmartFile vs. special township instructions), and identify your strongest basis (factual error, sale price, fair cash value, or comps).
If you want our help, we can step in as a practical “quality control” layer: tighten the argument, organize the exhibits, and make sure your packet matches the basis you selected—so you’re not losing on formatting when your facts deserve review.
Prefer a quick call first?
Call (312) 775-0980 and we’ll explain the process in plain English and what to gather next.
Frequently Asked Questions
Lake County tax appeals in plain English. Educational only; not legal advice.
Written By:
